Europe Union

Home Blog AI How Do AI Engineers Choose an LLM for Agentic AI?

How Do AI Engineers Choose an LLM for Agentic AI?

At the core of agentic AI are large language models. Not all LLMs are created equal however. They vary widely in reasoning ability, latency, cost, and how well they integrate into systems. With so many options on the market, choosing the right one can be overwhelming. That’s why, based on insights from Oleg Żero, we’ve created a practical questionnaire to help you evaluate and select the best LLM for your use case.

Want to build agentic AI for your organization, be the first to receive our video guide on how Oleg Żero, our AI engineer, builds AI agents. Join the waiting list.

Be the first to get agentic AI video series

Table Of Contents
show

17 questions that will help you choose the right LLM provider for agentic AI

To make this practical, we’ll break the decision into six key categories that actually determine whether your system works in production.

First, problem definition aka are you solving a clearly defined, measurable task, and do you even need an LLM? Then task complexity that will help you tackle whether you’re doing simple text transformation, reasoning, tool orchestration, or full agentic workflows. These two set the foundation, because model selection should always follow the nature of the problem, not benchmarks.

From there, we look at technical constraints: latency and scale (how fast and how often your system runs), data and domain (generic vs highly specialized knowledge), privacy and infrastructure (whether your data can leave your environment and what your team can support).

Finally, cost and reliability, because in agentic systems, costs grow quickly and errors compound across steps. Together, these six areas define the trade-offs that matter, and they’ll guide the questions we’re about to go through.

Be the First to See Oleg Żero’s Agentic AI Insights

Leave your email, and we’ll send you the videos as soon as they’re released.

Sign up for it

How to use this LLM provider checklist 

Go through each question and answer YES or NO based on your actual use case—not assumptions or future plans. Be honest: most mistakes happen when teams overestimate complexity or ignore constraints like cost, latency, or compliance.

As you answer, patterns will emerge. A majority of YES answers in complexity and agent-related questions means you’re building an agentic system where architecture matters more than the model. YES answers around privacy or infrastructure will immediately narrow your provider options, while scale and cost-related YES answers signal the need for optimization early on.

Finally, don’t treat this as a one-time exercise. Revisit the checklist as your system evolves because the “right” LLM choice often changes once real-world constraints, usage patterns, and costs become visible.

1. Are you solving the right problem?

Before choosing an LLM, you need to be sure the problem is clearly defined and measurable. Many teams apply LLMs where simpler, deterministic systems would work better. If the problem is vague, no model will give you reliable results.

  • Question 1: Is your task clearly defined and measurable?
  • Question 2: Is your problem bounded (e.g. classification, extraction), rather than generative or exploratory?
  • Question 3: Do you actually need an LLM here?

2. What kinds of tasks do you need your agents to do?

LLMs handle very different types of tasks, from simple text transformation to complex reasoning and multi-agent systems. The requirements change significantly depending on whether your system needs planning, tool use, or just basic processing. The more complex the task, the more your architecture matters over the model itself.

  • Question 4: Is this simple text transformation, or something more complex?
  • Question 5: Does my system require multi-step reasoning or planning?
  • Question 6: Does it need to call tools or external APIs?
  • Question 7: Am I building a multi-step or multi-agent system?

3. What technical constraints are you expecting to encounter?

Latency, scale, and system performance will shape which models are actually viable. What works in a prototype may fail under real production load or real-time requirements. These constraints often eliminate options before you even compare model quality.

  • Question 8: Do I need real-time or low-latency responses?
  • Question 9: Will this system run at high volume or production scale?
  • Question 10: Will errors compound across multiple steps?

4. How specialized is your problem?

Generic use cases can rely on general-purpose models, but specialized domains require deeper adaptation. This could mean retrieval-augmented generation, fine-tuning, or even domain-specific models. The more niche the problem, the less effective out-of-the-box models become.

  • Question 12: Do I require high factual accuracy or precision?

5. Where can your data go and what capacity do you have to host it?

Data privacy, compliance, and infrastructure capabilities are hard constraints, not preferences. In many cases, they determine whether you can use cloud APIs or need self-hosted solutions. Your team’s engineering maturity also plays a major role in what’s realistically achievable.

  • Question 13: Can my data be sent to external APIs?
  • Question 14: Am I operating under strict regulatory or compliance requirements?
  • Question 15: Do I have the infrastructure and team to support self-hosting?

6. How reliable and cost-effective is your system?

In production, costs scale quickly and errors compound across multi-step workflows. A system that looks good in isolation can break when exposed to real users and edge cases. The key is not just model quality, but whether the system is reliable and cost-effective over time.

  • Question 16: Can I estimate and monitor costs at scale?
  • Question 17: What is the cost of a wrong answer in my system?

Conclusion

Once you’ve answered these questions, your constraints become clear. You’ll know whether you need a fast and cheap model or a reasoning-heavy one, whether you can use a cloud API or must go private, and whether your biggest risk is cost, latency, or reliability.

And what’s next? Send us your answers. We’ll review your setup, challenge your assumptions, and help you design the right architecture and LLM strategy for your use case and not waste time going down the wrong path.

Be the first to get agentic AI video series

Are you ready to discuss your project with us? If so, simply fill in the form.

Contact us!

Send us an email: [email protected]